Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.
Ranked by verified ratings, mentions, and signature picks
Bar · Red Hook · $$$
Lightly battered fried calamari and shrimp
Pasta · Staten Island · $$$
Lightly battered and fried calamari with marinara
Steakhouse · Manhattan · $$$$
Italian · Manhattan · $$$
Crispy calamari rings with a zesty dipping sauce
Pasta · Manhattan · $$$$
A wildcard fusion dish that somehow works -- crispy pepperoni, tender calamari, and wok-kissed rice
Oyster Bar · Sunnyside · $$
Lightly battered calamari rings — a competent starter while you wait for the boil
Greek · Manhattan · $$$
Lightly fried calamari with a Mediterranean dipping sauce. A solid starter.
Pasta · Dyker Heights · $$$
Crispy fried calamari with marinara dipping sauce
American · Red Hook · $$$
Crispy fried calamari with cherry peppers and garlic butter — a New England classic.
Italian · Manhattan · $$
Crispy fried calamari, frequently lauded as the best, offering a satisfying crunch and savory flavor.
Italian · Manhattan · $$$$
Tender calamari, likely prepared with a classic preparation, offering a taste of the sea.
Manhattan · $$$$
Lightly fried calamari rings. A solid bar snack or dinner starter.
Pasta · Bay Ridge · $$
Light, crisp fried calamari served with sweet marinara sauce — voted best in Bay Ridge
Lightly fried calamari that's crispy without being greasy — available in a gluten-free version too.
New American · Mid Island · $$$
Crispy fried calamari served with a zesty spicy tomato dip, a popular choice for sharing.
Greek · Bayside · $$$
Lightly battered and fried squid rings served with lemon. Delicate crunch, not rubbery.
Pasta · Park Slope · $$$
Tender, lightly charred calamari — a lighter alternative to fried
Pasta · Stapleton Heights · $$$
Lightly fried Montauk calamari with house sauce
Crispy rings served with Romesco sauce -- solid but not spectacular
Pasta · Manhattan · $$$
Lightly fried squid with a tender bite and delicate crunch, served with a bright dipping sauce.
Pho & Noodles · Manhattan · $
Lightly battered and fried calamari. Crisp and well-seasoned.
New American · Staten Island · $$
Crispy calamari with Thai-inspired sweet chili glaze
Pasta · Carroll Gardens · $$
Crispy fried calamari that 'melts in your mouth'
Crispy, golden fried calamari — the consensus must-order starter that every table gets.
American · Howard Beach · $$$
Bar · Manhattan · $$$
Pasta · Clinton Hill · $$
Lightly battered and crispy, served with spicy tomato sauce — a solid starter
Pub & Grill · Sunnyside · $$
Lightly fried calamari with salt and chili seasoning — tender, not rubbery
Pasta · Manhattan · $$
Golden fried calamari rings served with marinara — a reliable starter to share.
Pasta · Little Italy · $$$
Tender calamari rings tossed with linguine in a flavorful red or white sauce.
Tender grilled calamari with fresh pesto sauce
Tender warm calamari over a lemony avocado dressing — a lighter, refreshing starter.
Vietnamese · Manhattan · $
Crispy battered calamari served with sweet chili lime sauce. The most praised appetizer.
Bar · Manhattan · $$
Steakhouse · Astoria · $$$$
Lightly battered calamari seasoned with salt and pepper. Crisp, tender, and well-seasoned.
Pasta · West Brighton · $$
Oyster Bar · Ozone Park · $$
Pasta · Howard Beach · $$$
Manhattan · $$$
Lightly battered and fried to a delicate crisp, served with a spicy dipping sauce that cuts through the richness cleanly
Pub & Grill · Manhattan · $$$
Lightly fried calamari rings with marinara sauce
African · Astoria · $$
A combo platter of grilled calamari and shrimp — crispy yet tender with Mediterranean seasoning.
Lightly battered squid rings fried crisp, served with tahina
Thai · Bayside · $$
Lightly battered and fried squid rings with a Thai dipping sauce.
Ramen · Manhattan · $$
Crispy fried squid with chili sauce and fresh garnish
Pasta · Little Italy · $$
Fried calamari rings served with marinara sauce.
Light, fresh calamari over greens — a good starter that pairs well with the cocktail program.