Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.
Ranked by verified ratings, mentions, and signature picks
Italian · Manhattan · $$$
Thin, blistered crust from the wood oven with classic toppings kept simple and well-balanced
Italian · Manhattan · $$
Thin-crust pizza from the wood-fired oven with good char and flavor — the most reliable order.
Thin, charred crust with a slightly chewy interior, topped with quality ingredients that don't overwhelm the base
Neapolitan-style pies with a properly blistered, chewy crust and restrained toppings that let the dough shine
A classic combination of tomato, mozzarella, and basil, a benchmark for any Italian pizzeria.
Pasta · Long Island City · $$$
Neapolitan-style wood-fired pizza — a reliable option alongside the pasta-heavy menu.
New American · Manhattan · $$
The kitchen's most consistent output — thin-crust pies with charred edges and straightforward, well-balanced toppings that hold up well for a bar-restaurant format.
Pasta · Manhattan · $$$
Coffee & Tea · Williamsburg · $$
Vegan pizza from the wood-fire oven — above average for plant-based pizza.
Pizza · Manhattan · $$$
A blistered, thin-crust pizza from the wood oven — a reliable casual order.
Roman-style thin crust with a charred, airy cornicione and high-quality toppings — the margherita and truffle variations are consistently praised for their balance and restraint
Pizza · Flatbush · $$
Hand-stretched pies with a charred, blistered crust from the wood oven — the house dough program is the centerpiece.
Thin, blistered crust with a properly charred undercarriage and high-quality toppings that don't overwhelm the base
Thin, charred crust with seasonal toppings that showcase the rooftop herb garden — the char-to-chew ratio is well-calibrated and consistently executed
Thin-crust pies with a properly blistered, charred edge from the wood-burning oven — the margherita and seasonal variations are consistently praised for their balance of sauce and char.
Bistro · Windsor Terrace · $$
Thin, blistered crust from the wood oven with bright tomato and creamy mozzarella — the test pizza
Blistered, thin-crust pies with charred edges from the wood oven — toppings are seasonal and restrained, which is the point
Thin, blistered crust with good char from the wood oven — the margherita and classic red-sauce variations are the most consistent
Pasta · Clinton Hill · $$
Thin-crust pies from the wood oven; the Margherita and a sausage option are the most-ordered
Pizza · Williamsburg · $$
Blistered, charred-crust pizza from the wood oven, a menu cornerstone
Thin-crust pies from the wood oven — the dish that built Mezzaluna's name
Pizza · Red Hook · $$
Classic margherita from the imported Italian wood-fired oven