Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.
Ranked by verified ratings, mentions, and signature picks
Diner · Manhattan · $$
Crispy pizza rolls with five cheeses and chili hot honey -- nostalgic, shareable, and dangerously addictive
Pizza · Manhattan · $$
Thin coal-charred crust with bright tomato sauce and a modest layer of mozzarella that lets the crust char shine
Pizza · Manhattan · $
Classic round cheese pie, 8 slices, the foundation of Suprema's reputation
A full 18-inch pie of Joe's classic cheese pizza. Eight slices of perfection.
Pizza · Mid Island · $$
Sweet fig preserves and creamy goat cheese on a thin crispy crust
Pizza · Port Richmond · $$
Classic cheese pizza on a dedicated gluten-free crust
Pizza · Ridgewood · $
Pizza · Clinton Hill · $$
Cocktail Bar · South Richmond Hill · $$
Pizza · Flatbush · $
Classic New York-style slice with a thin, foldable crust and a balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio
Pasta · Glen Oaks · $$
Thin-crust New York pie with bright marinara and stretchy mozzarella, sold by the pie or slice
Pizza · Williamsburg · $
Classic thin-crust NY slice with a well-balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio that's the backbone of the menu
Pizza · Jamaica · $
The default neighborhood NYC slice — thin, foldable, well-charred bottom, generous mozzarella
Pizza · Little Italy · $
Classic NY thin-crust cheese pie, crispy and foldable. The essentials done right.
A thick, square-cut pizza with a satisfyingly chewy crust and classic cheese topping.
Pizza · Howard Beach · $$
Classic NY-style pie with a thin, foldable crust and a balanced sweet tomato sauce
Year-round available heart-shaped cheese pizza, a viral and playful twist on classic NYC slice.
Thin charred crust with a light, bright tomato sauce and milky mozzarella in the classic 1933 style
Pizza · Rego Park · $
Classic NY slice with a crisp-bottomed, foldable crust and a balanced tomato-mozzarella ratio
A classic thin-crust pie with a generous, evenly browned cheese layer
The core counter offering at any New York slice shop — the baseline to judge the kitchen by
A creamy, ricotta-based pizza offering a rich alternative to tomato sauce.
Pizza · Bensonhurst · $
A standard New York-style pie — the core offering at a neighborhood pizzeria of this type
Pizza · Park Slope · $$
Classic New York-style pie from the pizzeria side of the menu.