Top Sicilian Square Slice dishes in New York

Ranked by verified ratings, mentions, and signature picks.

Eat Morels scores blend thousands of public reviews from across the web with ratings from Eat Morels diners — as diners weigh in, their ratings take the lead.

Sort

Nuovo York Pizza

3.71

Pizza · Manhattan · $

Sicilian Square Slice3.7· $5

Thick Sicilian-style square slice, named after famous NYC squares

Joe’s Pizza

3.28

Pizza · Manhattan · $

Sicilian Square Slice3.3· $5

Thick, airy Sicilian-style square slice with a crispy bottom and fluffy interior.

Mama's TOO! Pizzeria West Village

3.01

Pizza · Manhattan · $

Sicilian Square Slice2.6· $6

Focaccia-like crumb with a crisp fried bottom and bright tomato sauce, the family's signature style

Table 87

3.50

Pizza · Gowanus · $$

Sicilian Square Slice1.8· $4

Their signature thick-crust square — crispy bottom, airy interior, well-charred edges

Dani's House of Pizza

3.15

Pizza · Kew Gardens · $

Sicilian Square Slice1.7· $4

Thick airy crust with a crisp bottom and well-caramelized cheese edges — the signature here for decades

Change city

Want a ping when these happen?

Want a ping when these happen?

Top Sicilian Square Slice dishes in New York

Refine

Price

Cuisine

Neighborhood

Dietary

Nuovo York Pizza

Joe’s Pizza

Mama's TOO! Pizzeria West Village

Table 87

Dani's House of Pizza

Refine

Price

Cuisine

Neighborhood

Dietary