Sicily Osteria

Reliable Sicilian-Italian in the Theater District

Based on 3,183 reviews

Best for

• •Pre-theater diners needing a reliable, fast-enough meal before an 8pm curtain
• •Date nights looking for a warm, unfussy Italian backdrop
• •Groups celebrating with Italian staples and a long wine list
• •Out-of-towners who want a solid Italian meal near Times Square without the tourist-trap feel

Busiest

Weekday dinner (6-7:30pm, pre-theater rush)

Reservations

Recommended