Paul & Jimmy’s of Gramercy

Old-school Italian-American with solid red sauce classics

Based on 405 reviews

Best for

• •Date night for couples who want a warm, unpretentious setting without the fanfare of a trendy spot
• •Groups celebrating birthdays or anniversaries looking for classic Italian-American comfort
• •Pre-theater dinners for nearby Union Square or Baruch-area shows
• •Regulars and neighborhood locals who want consistent, familiar cooking
• •Wine drinkers who appreciate an approachable Italian-focused list

Busiest

Weekend dinner (7-9pm)

Reservations

Recommended