Change city

Rankings Search My Lists Download

Best dishes
About
Support
Privacy
Terms

Eat Morels. Know what to order.

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Pagan Idol Menu: What to Order in Union Square | Eat Morels

Pagan Idol

Union Square

Pagan Idol

Bar · Tiki Cocktails · $$

Pagan Idol

About this score

★★★★★★★★★★3.37Early score

The Eat Morels score blends thousands of public reviews from across the web with ratings from Eat Morels diners. As diners here weigh in, their ratings take the lead.

Public reviews from across the webIncluded

Eat Morels diner ratingsNone yet

This spot doesn't have Eat Morels ratings yet — be the first.

$25/person

Reserve ahead · busy weekdays

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Good to know

Get directions

Pagan Idol

What to Order

9 dishes

Daywalker
$15
Mr. Hanalei
Mr. Hanalei
Mai Tai Float
Mai Tai Float
Maybe Grog
Maybe Grog
Witch Doctor
Witch Doctor
Serpent and the Bird
Punch Bowl (Group)
Punch Bowl (Group)
Banana Life
Banana Life
The Volcano
The Volcano

All dishes · Pagan Idol

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Our Take

Immersive tiki escape with strong, theatrical rum cocktails

Based on 1,551 reviews

immersive tiki décor (volcano, shipwreck, starlit ceiling)strong, well‑crafted rum cocktailsgenerous pours and theatrical presentation

slow service during peak timesvirtually no food optionsoccasional brusque staff or door attitude

Best for: After-work drinks with colleagues (downtown location, lively vibe)
Celebrations or birthdays (immersive décor and theatrical cocktails)
Tiki enthusiasts seeking creative rum cocktails in a dramatic setting
Busiest: Weekday evenings, especially Fridays around 8–10 pm
Reservations: Recommended

Reviews

See all reviews

Atmosphere

Questions & Answers

Ask about Pagan Idol

Ask anything — about dishes, dietary options, ambiance, or reservations.

200 characters remaining

Questions about Pagan Idol

Menu

No menu photos yet — help others by sharing one.

Delete photo?

This menu photo will be removed for everyone. This can't be undone.

Report info for Pagan Idol

What's wrong?What should it say? (optional)More context (optional)0/500