O'Hara's Restaurant and Pub

Shepherd's Pie

Classic Irish shepherd's pie — hearty, warm, and homestyle

Guinness (on draft)

Perfectly poured, crisp and cold Irish stout—often cited as the best draft beer in NYC

Cheeseburger

A hearty pub cheeseburger and one of the most reliable orders on the menu

Wings

Bar wings tossed in a choice of sauces, a standard pairing with a Guinness

Wings

Bar wings tossed in a choice of sauces, a standard pairing with a Guinness

Irish Stew

Traditional Irish stew — the ultimate comfort food on a cold day

Smithwick’s Irish Ale (on draft)

Traditional Irish ale with smooth malt character, a reliable pub staple

Wings

Bar wings tossed in a choice of sauces, a standard pairing with a Guinness

Grilled NY Sirloin Steak

Surprisingly good pub steak — properly cooked and generously portioned

Brooklyn Lager (on draft)

Clean, balanced American lager from local Brooklyn brewery—great crowd‑pleaser

Irish Nachos

Potato-based nachos with Irish twist — a fun pub snack

Angry Orchard Hard Cider (bottle)

Crisp, refreshing hard cider—popular among reviewers who prefer cider over beer

Broiled Salmon

Simply broiled salmon — a lighter pub option

Vodka & ginger ale (vanilla Stoli)

Simple, clean vodka‑based drink—reviewers mention vanilla Stoli with ginger ale as a go‑to

Buffalo Chicken Tenders

Spicy, crispy chicken tenders — classic bar food done well

Grilled Cheese with bacon and tomato

Oversized, messy grilled cheese loaded with bacon and tomato—so good you’ll need a fork

Reuben Sandwich

Hearty corned beef, Swiss and sauerkraut on rye—classic and satisfying

Roast Beef Sandwich