Based on 15,464 reviews
Dense, impossibly creamy with a thin graham cracker crust — the canonical version of the style, not fluffy or airy but firm and rich through every bite
The house cheesecake crowned with a glossy strawberry topping — the most-ordered variation and the image that appears on every box they ship nationwide
Thick-cut, peppery pastrami piled high on rye bread — one of the better pastrami sandwiches in Midtown, even if it can't compete with the dedicated delis
Classic Jewish deli-style broth with a fluffy, properly seasoned matzo ball — comforting and well-executed for a diner setting
