five generations of family ownershipsignature dishes unchanged since 1941fresh local mozzarella
sizeable portions
warm family atmosphere
not the flashiest spot on the avenuedecor is datedlimited online presence
$35/person
Best for: families looking for tradition · history buffs and food nerds · homestyle Neapolitan cooking · medium-budget Italian dinner · multi-generational dining
Reviews
Menu
No menu photos yet — help others by sharing one.
Signature Items
5 dishes
Family-owned since 1927. Some dishes unchanged since 1941. Reservations available via OpenTable.
Chicken Ann & Tony's
$24.00
The house signature chicken dish, on the menu since 1941. A family recipe spanning five generations.
Shrimp Ann & Tony's
$24.00
The house signature shrimp preparation, also dating back to 1941.
Ann & Tony's Spritz
$13.00
The house cocktail, a refreshing Italian spritz.
V
Homemade Pasta
$20.00
Fresh pasta made in-house, served with your choice of sauce.
V
Fresh Mozzarella Appetizer
$12.00
Just-made mozzarella sourced from the Arthur Avenue neighborhood.