Change city

Rankings Search My Lists

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Best Restaurants in City Island, New York | Eat Morels

Best Restaurants in City Island

Ranked by food quality, community ratings, and freshness · 21 restaurants

Vistamar Restaurant & Lounge

Vistamar Restaurant & Lounge

American·$$·$45/person

Seafood Paella$76Whole Red Snapper$45Lobster Mac & Cheese$28

City Island Pizza Company

City Island Pizza Company

Pizza·$$·$25/person

Red Pie$18Red Hot Chili Pepper Pie

$22

Sunday Supper$25

Little Greece

Little Greece

Greek·$·$18/person

Lamb/Beef Gyro Platter$19Mini-Gyro Flight$16Pastitio Platter$20

Little Frida's Eatery

Little Frida's Eatery

Taqueria·$·$15/person

Tacos de Birria$14Beef Tacos$12Chipotle Chicken Quesadilla$13

ATIK Restaurant

ATIK Restaurant

American·$$·$40/person

Skirt Steak over Porcini Risotto$38Homemade Meatballs$18Braised Short Rib$36

Clipper Coffee

Clipper Coffee

Coffee·$·$8/person

Avocado Toast$8Cheddar Scallion Scone$4Tiramisu Latte$5

City Island Lobster House

City Island Lobster House

Restaurant·$$$·$50/person

Steamed Whole LobsterMaine Lobster$38Twin Lobster Tail Platter$55

The Black Whale

The Black Whale

New American·$$·$35/person

Seared Sesame-Crusted Tuna Salad$29Pan Seared Maryland Crab Cakes$12Chicken Empanadas$9

The Snug

The Snug

American·$$·$25/person

Fish and Chips$16Prickly PearAloe Vera

Archie's Tap & Table

Archie's Tap & Table

New American·$$·$40/person

Saffron Glazed Shrimp$16Pineapple Gochujang Wings$13Buttermilk Fried Chicken$24

Scavello's On The Island

Scavello's On The Island

Italian·$$·$45/person

Oysters Rockefeller$20Colossal Crab Cake$17Grilled Octopus$16

Sammy's Fish Box

Sammy's Fish Box

American·$$$·$55/person

Combination Platter$109Twin Lobsters$65Tropical Cocktails

JP's

JP's

American·$$$·$55/person

Broiled Seafood Combo for Two$75Fried Calamari$16Twin Lobster Tails$48

Johnny's Reef

Johnny's Reef

Restaurant·$·$18/person

Fried Shrimp$11Fried Scallops$11Fried Oysters$11

City Island Diner

City Island Diner

Diner·$·$15/person

Sailmaker Omelet$12Fluffy Pancakes$10Hurricane Omelet$14

Tony's Pier

Tony's Pier

Restaurant·$$·$25/person

Fried Shrimp PlatterFried Scallops$12Fried Calamari$11

Sea Shore Restaurant

Sea Shore Restaurant

Oyster Bar·$$·$40/person

Sea Shore Broiled Seafood Combination$43New England Clam Chowder$10Sauteed Scallops$45

The Original Crab Shanty

The Original Crab Shanty

Oyster Bar·$$·$40/person

Alaskan King Crab Legs$50Joe V Deep Diver Feast$70Broiled Shrimp$15

Seafood City

Seafood City

Restaurant·$$·$25/person

Fried Seafood Combo$39Fried Shrimp$18Seafood Paella$24

Sammy's Smokehouse

Sammy's Smokehouse

BBQ·$$·$45/person

Prime Brisket$35St. Louis Ribs$40Smokehouse Paella$55

Seafood Kingz 2 Inc

Seafood Kingz 2 Inc

American·$$·$30/person

Coconut Shrimp$18Steamed Shrimp and Broccoli$20Fried Catfish$18