Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.
Ranked by verified ratings, mentions, and signature picks
Burgers · Old Toronto · $$
Double-patty cheeseburger with crispy-edged beef, melted cheese, and the works — this is the benchmark order that made the reputation
Double-patty cheeseburger with fresh-ground beef cooked to a seared, lacy edge — their definitive item and the reason regulars come back weekly
Their namesake smash burger with fresh-ground beef, American cheese, and a soft bun — the textbook version of what this style should be
Burgers · Old Toronto · $
Double smash patty with American cheese, the caramelized beef edges are the whole point — crispy, juicy, and deeply savoury in every bite
Double smash patty with sharp cheddar and special sauce — the quintessential order for anyone who wants the full Burger's Priest experience
Single patty version — leaner, faster, but the same high-quality fresh beef and tight construction as its bigger sibling
The single-patty entry point — still exemplary thanks to the fresh-ground beef, ideal if you want to judge the baseline before going bigger
The entry-level single patty burger — clean and straightforward, showing off the quality of the beef without distraction
A larger regular-menu option for those who want more beef without diving into full secret-menu territory
