Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.
Ranked by verified ratings, mentions, and signature picks
Pizza · Manhattan · $
Thick Sicilian-style square slice, named after famous NYC squares
Thick, airy Sicilian-style square slice with a crispy bottom and fluffy interior.
Pizza · Manhattan · $$
Thick square Sicilian-style slice with a pillowy dough base
Thick, focaccia-style square with a fluffy interior and crisped bottom — less consistent than the round slices but worth it when fresh
Focaccia-like crumb with a crisp fried bottom and bright tomato sauce, the family's signature style
Pizza · Howard Beach · $
Square, thicker-crust slice with a fluffy crumb and crisp bottom, topped with sauce and cheese
Thick square with a crisp bottom and a bright tomato sauce, a lighter counterpoint to the artichoke
A skillet-sized rectangular slice with a thick airy crust and a tomato-blanketed top — the reason the line forms
Pizza · Gowanus · $$
Their signature thick-crust square — crispy bottom, airy interior, well-charred edges
Pizza · Kew Gardens · $
Thick airy crust with a crisp bottom and well-caramelized cheese edges — the signature here for decades
Pizza · DUMBO · $
Thick-crust square slice with a hearty layer of sauce and cheese.
Park Slope · $
Thick airy square with a crisp underside and an honest tomato sauce, a local favorite
