Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.
Ranked by verified ratings, mentions, and signature picks
Pizza · Manhattan · $
Thick Sicilian-style square with generous pepperoni and a spicy kick. Crispy bottom, pillowy interior.
Classic pepperoni with curled, crispy edges on a perfectly thin crust.
Pizza · Manhattan · $$
Classic pepperoni slice on Joe's signature thin crust
Cupped, slightly crispy pepperoni that pools grease in the center — the way it should be done on a New York slice
Pizza · Ridgewood · $
Pizza · Bushwick · $
Pizza · Kew Gardens · $
Generously layered crisp-cup pepperoni over a well-charred New York base, the slice that built the line
Pizza · Brooklyn Heights · $
Cup-and-char pepperoni curling into crisp grease-filled cups over the chewy, well-developed crust
Classic slice topped with cup-and-char-style pepperoni
A standard slice topped with crisped pepperoni
Cup-and-char pepperoni crisping into little oil-pooled cups atop the signature charred crust
Crisp cup-and-char pepperoni over a thin, well-developed crust with a balanced sauce
A popular choice featuring a thin crust generously topped with pepperoni.
Pizza · DUMBO · $
Classic pepperoni slice with cups of crispy, slightly charred pepperoni on a thin crust.
A classic slice with crisp pepperoni over the signature Joe's crust
Cheese slice topped with cupping pepperoni that crisps and pools oil
