Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.
Ranked by verified ratings, mentions, and signature picks
Pizza · College Hill · $
A loaded slice topped with elbow mac and cheese sauce — the gimmick that became a signature
Pizza · Federal Hill · $
Foldable New York-style slice with a thin, crackly crust and slightly sweet tomato sauce
Pizza · Fox Point · $
Wide, foldable New York-style slice with crackly bottom and balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio
Pizza · Smithfield · $
Wide, thin, foldable slice with crisp bottom and tangy red sauce — the house's bread and butter
Pizza · Elmhurst · $
Standard NY-style slice with a foldable crust — the default order and what most regulars are here for
Wide NY-style slice with a foldable crust — the baseline against which the specialty slices are judged
